Beyond the Espresso Martini: 5 Coffee Cocktails to Warm Up Your Holiday Parties

Let's be honest: the espresso martini has had its moment. Actually, it's had several moments. From its 1980s London origins to its recent TikTok-fueled renaissance, this frothy caffeinated cocktail has become the default "coffee drink" at bars everywhere. And while there's absolutely nothing wrong with a well-made espresso martini—I'll never turn one down—it's time we expanded our horizons.

This holiday season, as we're planning gatherings and thinking about what to serve, coffee cocktails deserve a serious second look. They're warming, energizing, and sophisticated enough for evening entertaining while being approachable enough that even your uncle who "doesn't do fancy drinks" will enjoy them. Plus, let's talk about practicality: serving coffee cocktails means your guests get a little pick-me-up alongside their buzz, which can be exactly what's needed during those long holiday evenings that stretch from dinner into late-night conversations.

The beauty of coffee as a cocktail ingredient goes far beyond the espresso martini's vodka-and-espresso formula. Coffee brings depth, bitterness, and complexity that can complement everything from aged spirits to cream liqueurs to spiced rums. It plays well with the warming spices we associate with the holidays—cinnamon, nutmeg, cardamom—and it provides a perfect canvas for seasonal flavors.

So let's explore five coffee cocktails that will absolutely elevate your holiday entertaining game. These drinks range from classic recipes that deserve more attention to modern innovations that are taking over craft cocktail menus. Each one offers something different, whether you're looking for a dessert-style sipper, a bold after-dinner drink, or something to serve a crowd without spending all night behind your home bar.

Before you skip this thinking "everyone knows about Irish coffee," hear me out. Most people have only had mediocre versions of this drink—either too sweet, made with subpar coffee, or served in the wrong glass without that crucial cream float. A properly made Irish coffee is a revelation, and it's absolutely perfect for holiday gatherings.

The Irish coffee was created in the 1940s at Foynes Port in Ireland by chef Joe Sheridan, who wanted to warm up cold travelers. The drink made its way to San Francisco's Buena Vista Cafe in the 1950s, where it became an institution. The recipe is deceptively simple: hot coffee, Irish whiskey, sugar, and lightly whipped cream floated on top.

Here's how to do it right:

Start with a proper Irish coffee glass or a clear, heat-safe stemmed glass. The visual of the dark coffee and the cream layer is part of the experience. Preheat your glass with hot water, then dump it out. Add one to two teaspoons of brown sugar (more complex than white sugar), then pour in about 1.5 ounces of good Irish whiskey. Fill the glass about three-quarters full with hot, strong coffee—not espresso, but proper drip or French press coffee. Stir well to dissolve the sugar.

Now for the crucial part: the cream. You want heavy cream that's been lightly whipped—not to stiff peaks, but just until it starts to thicken and can float on the surface of the coffee. Pour it slowly over the back of a spoon so it sits on top of the coffee rather than mixing in. The drink should be sipped through the cream, so each sip delivers that perfect combination of bitter coffee, smooth whiskey, and rich cream.

For holiday gatherings, you can set up an Irish coffee bar with different whiskey options (a smooth Jameson, a richer Redbreast, or even an American whiskey for variation), various sugars (demerara, maple syrup, brown sugar), and let guests customize their drinks. It's interactive, warming, and feels appropriately festive.

If you haven't encountered the carajillo yet, you're in for a treat. This Spanish coffee cocktail has been quietly taking over cocktail menus, and for good reason—it's incredibly easy to make, visually stunning, and absolutely delicious.

The traditional carajillo is just two ingredients: espresso and Licor 43, a Spanish liqueur with vanilla, citrus, and spice notes. The name allegedly comes from Spanish soldiers in Cuba who would add rum to their coffee for "courage" (coraje), though the etymology is debated. Regardless of its origins, the modern carajillo typically uses Licor 43, though you'll find variations with rum, brandy, or other spirits.

The build is simple:

In a heat-safe glass, pour about 1.5 ounces of Licor 43. Separately, pull a fresh shot of espresso. You can serve it two ways: the Spanish method, where you light the Licor 43 briefly to warm and caramelize the flavors before adding the espresso, or the more common modern approach where you simply pour the espresso directly over the liqueur. The result is layered, aromatic, and beautifully balanced between sweetness and coffee bitterness.

For a holiday twist, try adding a cinnamon stick, a splash of spiced rum, or even a flamed orange peel. Serve it after dinner, with dessert, or—let's be honest—anytime you need a warm pick-me-up that feels special without requiring much effort.

The espresso martini may be the most famous vodka-and-coffee drink, but the Black Russian walked so it could run. Created in the late 1940s, this cocktail is just two ingredients: vodka and coffee liqueur. Don’t underestimate it—its simplicity is exactly what makes it great.

To make one, fill a rocks glass with ice. Add 2 ounces of vodka and 1 ounce of coffee liqueur (usually Kahlúa, though there are excellent craft versions now). Stir gently. That’s it. The result is dark, velvety, and surprisingly complex considering how easy it is to make.

For holiday gatherings, you can batch Black Russians easily—just multiply the ratio and store in a chilled pitcher. Add a few dashes of chocolate bitters or a hint of orange zest for a winter twist.

If you love whiskey cocktails, the Revolver is your new cold-weather favorite. Created in the early 2000s in San Francisco, it’s essentially a Manhattan with a coffee-infused kick: bourbon, coffee liqueur, and orange bitters.

To build one, combine 2 ounces of bourbon and ½ ounce of coffee liqueur in a mixing glass with ice. Add two dashes of orange bitters. Stir until chilled, then strain into a coupe or Nick and Nora glass.

Finish with a flamed orange peel if you’re feeling dramatic—it adds an incredible aroma and makes the drink feel instantly festive.

This is a sophisticated, spirit-forward drink that works beautifully as an after-dinner sip or a warming holiday cocktail by the fireplace.

The White Russian has never really gone out of style, but it’s especially perfect for the holidays. Creamy, indulgent, and ridiculously easy to make, it’s basically the adult version of a boozy iced latte.

Fill a rocks glass with ice. Add 2 ounces vodka and 1 ounce coffee liqueur. Top with heavy cream or half-and-half—some people like to float it, others prefer to stir. Either way, it’s rich, cozy, and tastes like a liquid dessert.

For holiday variations, try adding peppermint schnapps, cinnamon liqueur, or a dash of nutmeg. You can even make a "Gingerbread White Russian" by adding ginger syrup or a holiday-spiced coffee liqueur.

The Final Word

Coffee cocktails are far more versatile than most people realize, and the holidays are the perfect time to explore beyond the espresso martini. Whether you want something creamy and dessert-like, something boozy and bold, or something simple you can build in seconds, there’s a coffee-based drink that fits the moment.

Try one, try all five, or serve a mix at your holiday party. Your guests will thank you—especially around 10 p.m. when the caffeine starts kicking in.

You Might Also Like

Espresso Martini

Irish Coffee